Originally posted by on a forum
DL:
Of course the cat is dead or alive. It's only the human measuring problem.
Uncertainty in relation to measuring is OK (there are many manufacturing limits related to machinery limits and material limits when you make for example tennis-racquets) , but making from that measuring-problem a general projection on "concepts" is quiet questionable. These are different things.
It's like saying as an tennis-racquet inventor to the tennis manufacture: This is the concept design in general but I don't know exactly how you must fix the strings 10 to 15 to that part of the tennis frame ... so please start production and finish it ... and start to deliver to Nike".
Some months ago Osher (postings a reaction on superstringtheory.com) pointed out that : "There are two meaning of Uncertainty, (1) error, like x2 - x1 or dx, and (2) standard deviation or its square variance which is the only technically correct definition used by mathematical probability and statistics people. Error itself is replaced by standard deviation precisely because it is so fluctuating (negatively and positively) that it often cancels itself out or else overexaggerates in random directions, but standard deviation isn't a major tool for engineering or for that matter for physical laws because most physical laws relate VARIABLES (even RANDOM VARIABLES) rather than their statistical population standard deviations or population means. Einstein, Schrodinger, Bohr, Heisenberg, all made the mistake of not understanding that."
Maybe it's better to rename Quantum Mechanics to Qualm Mechanics.
-----------------------------
Thanks Croot,
the problem is that from a measuring problem a world/reality image is created that is based on super-position. Super-position is anti-unity as a concept. From the top there is causality, hierachy, ... not anarchy. The start maybe chaotic but the further developments - on the brane - were historical consequent. Uncertainty only exists is the human ignorance and the lack of logic explanation.
|